As a legal expert with a focus on employment law, I can provide an analysis of the legality of personality assessments in the context of employment. It is important to note that laws and regulations can vary by jurisdiction, and this discussion is meant to provide a general overview rather than specific legal advice.

Personality assessments are a common tool used by employers to evaluate the suitability of job candidates for specific positions. These assessments aim to measure various aspects of an individual's personality, such as their traits, behaviors, and attitudes, which can be relevant to job performance. The legal considerations surrounding the use of personality assessments primarily revolve around employment discrimination laws, privacy laws, and medical examination regulations.

Employment Discrimination Laws: In the United States, the **Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC)** provides guidance on the use of assessments in employment. According to EEOC guidance, employers may use personality assessments as part of their hiring process, but they must ensure that these assessments do not discriminate against applicants based on protected characteristics such as race, sex, religion, age, or disability. The assessments should be job-related and consistent with business necessity. This means that the assessment must be designed to measure qualities that are genuinely required for the job and that there is a valid reason for why these qualities are being measured.

Privacy Laws: With the increasing use of technology and data collection, privacy has become a significant concern. Employers must ensure that the use of personality assessments complies with privacy laws. This includes obtaining informed consent from candidates before administering the assessment and ensuring that the data collected is used and stored in a manner that respects the privacy rights of the individuals. Additionally, employers should be transparent about how the assessment results will be used and provide candidates with the opportunity to review and contest any findings.

Medical Examination Regulations: The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) prohibits employers from conducting medical examinations before making a job offer, unless it is shown to be job-related and consistent with business necessity. Personality assessments are generally not considered medical examinations under the ADA. However, if an assessment includes questions about an individual's physical or mental health conditions, it may be considered a medical examination and thus subject to ADA regulations.

Best Practices: To ensure legality and ethical use of personality assessments, employers should:


1. Validate the Assessment: Ensure that the assessment is scientifically valid and has been tested for its ability to predict job performance.

2. Job Relevance: Clearly define how the assessment results will be used and ensure that the assessment measures job-related qualities.

3. Candidate Consent: Obtain informed consent from candidates before administering the assessment.

4. Data Security: Implement measures to protect the confidentiality and security of the assessment data.

5. Transparency: Be transparent with candidates about the purpose and use of the assessment.

6. Review and Contest: Allow candidates the opportunity to review their assessment results and contest any findings if they believe there are inaccuracies.

In conclusion, personality assessments can be legally used by employers for hiring purposes, provided they adhere to employment discrimination laws, respect privacy laws, and comply with medical examination regulations. Employers must take a thoughtful and careful approach to ensure that their use of personality assessments is fair, ethical, and legally sound.

read more >>

According to EEOC guidance, employers may give psychological examinations to job applicants so long as the examination is not medical. ... Thus, most integrity tests would not be considered medical examinations under the ADA. PRIVACY. An issue of growing legal concern for employers using personality testing is privacy.read more >>