As a home energy consultant with extensive experience in the field of heating systems, I'm often asked to compare the costs of different types of heating options. When it comes to the question of whether a gas furnace is cheaper than an electric one, the answer is not straightforward and depends on several factors including the cost of fuel, the efficiency of the heating system, the size of the home, local climate, and utility rates.

Firstly, the cost of fuel is a significant factor. Natural gas is generally cheaper than electricity on a per-unit basis. However, the efficiency of the heating system also plays a crucial role. Gas furnaces are typically more efficient than electric furnaces, with gas models having an average Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency (AFUE) of about 80% to 90%, while electric models are 100% efficient in converting electricity to heat. The difference in efficiency can affect the overall cost of operation.

Secondly, the size of the home and the local climate are also important. In colder climates, a more efficient heating system is necessary to maintain a comfortable temperature, and the choice between gas and electric may be influenced by the availability and cost of natural gas in the area. For larger homes, the difference in efficiency can lead to a significant difference in energy consumption and, consequently, cost.

Thirdly, utility rates vary by region and can greatly affect the cost of operating a heating system. In some areas, the cost of electricity is much higher than that of natural gas, making gas furnaces a more economical choice. Conversely, in regions where electricity is cheaper, electric furnaces may be more cost-effective.

It's also important to consider the initial cost of the heating system itself. Electric furnaces are generally less expensive to purchase and install than gas furnaces. However, this initial cost savings must be weighed against the potential long-term savings from lower fuel costs with a gas furnace.

Lastly, as mentioned, there is a third option to consider: electric heat pumps. Electric heat pumps are highly energy efficient and can provide both heating and cooling, making them an attractive alternative. They extract heat from the outside air and transfer it inside, which can be more cost-effective than traditional heating methods, especially in moderate climates.

In conclusion, the decision between a gas furnace and an electric furnace should be based on a comprehensive analysis of the factors mentioned above. It's essential to consider the long-term costs and benefits, including the initial investment, operating costs, and the environmental impact of each system.

read more >>

There is, however, a third option when it comes to electric vs. gas heating: an electric heat pump. Electric heat pumps are more energy efficient than gas furnaces and require much less electricity to operate than electric furnaces.read more >>