As a culinary expert with a deep understanding of the chemistry of ingredients and their impact on the final product, I can provide a comprehensive answer to your question about substituting margarine for butter in baking.

Firstly, it's important to understand that margarine and butter are not identical in composition, which means they will not always behave the same way in recipes.
Butter is a dairy product made from cream, and it contains a high percentage of milk fat, which contributes to the rich flavor and texture of baked goods. Butter also contains water and milk solids, which can affect the leavening process and the final texture of the baked product.

Margarine, on the other hand, is a vegetable fat product that is designed to mimic the properties of butter. It is made from vegetable oils that have been hydrogenated to make them solid at room temperature. The hydrogenation process can create trans fats, which, as you mentioned, are known to be harmful to health. However, not all margarine contains trans fats; many modern margarines are made with oils that do not contain these harmful fats.

When considering substituting margarine for butter, there are several factors to take into account:


1. Fat Content: Margarine and butter have different fat contents. Butter is about 80% fat, while margarine can vary from 60% to 80% fat. This difference can affect the richness and texture of your baked goods.


2. Melting Point: Butter has a lower melting point than most margarines. This can impact how your baked goods rise and set.


3. Flavor: Butter imparts a distinct flavor to baked goods that margarine may not be able to replicate, especially in recipes where the flavor of butter is a key component.


4. Leavening: The water content in butter can contribute to the leavening process in baking, helping the dough to rise. Margarine, depending on its composition, may not provide the same effect.


5. Texture: The texture of margarine can be similar to that of butter, but it may not cream with sugar as well, which can affect the crumb and texture of cakes and cookies.


6. Health Considerations: While trans fats are a concern, modern margarines are often made with healthier oils. However, the overall health impact of using margarine versus butter will depend on the specific product and its ingredients.

7.
Type of Margarine: As you mentioned, there are different types of margarine, such as stick margarine and tub margarine. Stick margarine, also known as block or hard margarine, has a similar texture to butter and is often considered a better substitute for baking and cooking. Tub margarine, which is softer and more spreadable, may not be as suitable for certain baking recipes.

8.
Recipe Specificity: Some recipes are very specific about the use of butter, especially in traditional or artisanal baking. Substituting margarine may not yield the same results.

9.
Experimentation: If you decide to substitute margarine for butter, it may take some experimentation to find the right balance and achieve the desired results.

10.
Label Reading: Always read the labels of margarine products to understand their composition, especially looking for the presence of trans fats and the type of oils used.

In conclusion, while margarine can be substituted for butter in some baking recipes, it is not a one-to-one swap due to differences in composition and properties. It's essential to consider the type of margarine, the specific recipe, and the desired outcome when making this substitution. For best results, it's often recommended to follow the recipe as written, especially in baking where small changes can have a significant impact.

read more >>

Stick margarine, also known as block or hard margarine, has the same texture as butter, and is therefore a better substitute for baking and cooking than tub margarine. However, stick margarines are generally high in trans fats, which have been shown to be bad for our heart.read more >>