As an expert in the field of military hierarchies and their representation in various forms of media, including the expansive universe of "Star Wars," I can provide a detailed analysis of the ranking system within the context of the franchise. It's important to note that the "Star Wars" universe, created by George Lucas, is a work of fiction with its own set of rules and hierarchies that may not always align with real-world military structures. However, for the sake of comparison and understanding, we can draw some parallels.
In the "Star Wars" universe, the term "Captain" is often used to denote a high-ranking officer within the Imperial Navy. The Imperial Navy is the space-based military arm of the Galactic Empire, and its officers are responsible for commanding starships and carrying out the Emperor's will across the galaxy. Captains in the Imperial Navy, such as Captain Needa from "The Empire Strikes Back," are typically in charge of large capital ships like Star Destroyers.
On the other hand, the title of "Commander" is also used within the Imperial ranks, but it can be a bit more ambiguous. In some cases, a Commander may hold a position of authority over a specific unit or operation, while in others, they may serve as a second-in-command to a Captain or higher-ranking officer. For example, Commander Lorth Needa, who is Captain Needa's brother, holds a position of authority on a Star Destroyer but is not in charge of the entire vessel.
When comparing the two ranks, if we are strictly looking at naval ranks within the Imperial Navy, a Captain would generally be considered higher in rank than a Commander. This is similar to many real-world navies where the rank of Captain is above Commander. However, it's important to remember that the "Star Wars" universe is not strictly bound by real-world military conventions, and the specific hierarchy can vary depending on the context and the particular chain of command in question.
It's also worth mentioning that the term "Commander" can have different implications in different branches of the military within the "Star Wars" universe. For instance, within the Imperial Army, the rank of Commander might carry more weight than in the Navy, given the differences in the size and scope of their operations. But again, without specific context, it's difficult to make a direct comparison.
In conclusion, within the context of the Imperial Navy in "Star Wars," a Captain is typically higher in rank than a Commander. However, the specific dynamics of rank and command can vary, and the "Star Wars" universe often takes creative liberties with its military hierarchy to serve the narrative. It's always best to consider the context in which these ranks are used within the story.
read more >>

Heh heh oh God ranks in Star Wars. IF we are talking about ranks in the only fairly organized military we see (the Empire's) then assuming both are Navy ranks, like in the real world, Captain outranks a Commander. (HOWEVER, if we are comparing an ARMY captain to a NAVY commander, the Commander ranks.read more >>