As a subject matter expert in military hierarchy and protocol, I'd like to address the question of whether Army Cadets outrank enlisted personnel, specifically non-commissioned officers (NCOs). The U.S. Army has a structured ranking system that delineates the authority and responsibilities of each individual within the military. Understanding this hierarchy is crucial for maintaining order and discipline.
The reference to AR 600-20, which is the Army Regulation concerning the "Army Command Policy," is indeed a key document in this discussion. This regulation outlines the order of precedence for military personnel, and it is designed to clarify any potential confusion regarding rank and authority within the Army.
According to AR 600-20, the ranking order places cadet ranks after those of commissioned and warrant officers but before non-commissioned officers (NCOs). This means that a West Point cadet, while not yet a commissioned officer, holds a position of authority that technically places them above an NCO in terms of rank structure. This is a nuanced aspect of military protocol that is not always immediately apparent to those outside of the service.
However, it's important to note that the practical application of this ranking can vary based on context. In the day-to-day operations of a military unit, an NCO with years of experience and leadership responsibilities may hold significant sway and respect, regardless of the technical ranking of a cadet. The military values experience and leadership, and in many cases, the deference given to an NCO in practical terms may outweigh the formal ranking structure.
That being said, during formal ceremonies, inspections, and other situations where rank is explicitly recognized, a West Point cadet would be acknowledged as ranking above an NCO. This is a matter of protocol and is adhered to in order to maintain the integrity of the military's chain of command.
In conclusion, while it is technically correct that a West Point cadet outranks an Army NCO according to AR 600-20, the actual dynamics of rank and authority within the military can be more complex. The military operates on a blend of formal rank structure and the respect accorded to individuals based on their experience and leadership qualities. It's a balance that ensures both order and flexibility within the ranks.
read more >>

The NCO referred me to AR 600-20, Army Command Policy, which makes it pretty clear that West Point cadets do, in fact, outrank Army NCOs. This regulation shows that cadets rank after commissioned and warrant officers, but before NCOs. ... You're right, Sergeant, a West Point cadet DOES outrank you. Technically.Jun 28, 2016read more >>