best answer > How does Circe both help and hinder Odysseus?- QuesHub | Better Than Quora
  • How does Circe both help and hinder Odysseus?

    修斯 先知 的人

    Questioner:Ava Roberts 2018-06-14 18:59:53
The most authoritative answer in 2024
  • Noah Lee——Works at the World Health Organization, Lives in Geneva, Switzerland.

    As a scholar with a deep understanding of classical literature and mythology, I am well-versed in the intricacies of Homer's "Odyssey," a tale of the hero Odysseus and his journey home from the Trojan War. One of the most fascinating characters in this epic is Circe, a sorceress who plays a dual role in Odysseus's journey. She is both an obstacle and a guide, and her actions have profound implications for Odysseus's quest to return to Ithaca. Let's delve into the ways in which Circe both hinders and helps Odysseus. **Step 1: Hindrance - The Enchantment of Odysseus's Men** Circe's initial interaction with Odysseus is one of hindrance. When Odysseus and his crew arrive at her island, they are greeted by a feast. However, the food is enchanted, and those who partake are transformed into swine. This is a direct impediment to Odysseus's progress, as it results in the loss of his men, at least temporarily. The men's transformation into animals is a metaphor for the loss of their humanity and the challenges Odysseus faces in maintaining the loyalty and integrity of his crew throughout his journey. **Step 2: Assistance - The Counteracting of the Enchantment** Despite her initial hindrance, Circe also provides assistance to Odysseus. She reveals the antidote to the enchantment and instructs Odysseus on how to reverse the spell that has befallen his men. This act not only restores his crew to their human form but also establishes Circe as a character who, despite her initial malevolence, can be a source of aid and wisdom. **Step 3: Guidance - The Prophecy of Tiresias** Circe's role as a guide is further exemplified when she informs Odysseus that he must seek out the blind prophet Tiresias in the underworld. This journey is crucial for Odysseus's understanding of his destiny and the steps he must take to reach Ithaca. Circe's guidance here is pivotal; without her advice, Odysseus might have been lost, both literally and figuratively. **Step 4: The Temptation and Punishment - Helios' Cattle** The story of Circe and Odysseus also includes a significant event where her warning becomes a test of Odysseus's leadership. Circe warns Odysseus about the dangers of the island of Helios, where the crew must not harm the sacred cattle of the sun god. Despite her warning, Odysseus's men, driven by hunger and desperation, kill the cattle. This act leads to their doom, as the ship is destroyed, and only Odysseus survives, further delaying his return home. **Step 5: The Dual Nature of Circe's Character** Circe's character in "The Odyssey" is a complex one, embodying both the allure and the danger of the unknown. She represents the seductive power of magic and the potential for humans to be led astray by their desires. At the same time, she provides Odysseus with the knowledge and tools necessary to overcome the obstacles in his path. Her duality serves as a reminder of the multifaceted nature of assistance and hindrance in the hero's journey. In conclusion, Circe is a character who both hinders and helps Odysseus, reflecting the dual nature of many challenges faced by heroes in mythology. Her actions test Odysseus's character, force him to make difficult decisions, and ultimately contribute to his growth as a leader and a man. read more >>
  • Oliver Jackson——Works at the International Renewable Energy Agency, Lives in Abu Dhabi, UAE.

    How does Circe both hinder and help Odysseus? Circe hinders Odysseus by turning his men into swine. She helps him by telling him he must go see Tiresias, a blind prophet of Thebes, in the land of the dead. ... When Odysseus' men are tempted by food, they give into the temptation and kill Helios' cattle.read more >>

about “修斯、先知、的人”,people ask:

READ MORE:

QuesHub is a place where questions meet answers, it is more authentic than Quora, but you still need to discern the answers provided by the respondents.

分享到

取消