As a historian with a focus on ancient civilizations, I have spent considerable time studying the narratives and myths surrounding the Trojan War, which is a significant event in Greek mythology. The question of who killed Menelaus in Troy is a complex one, as it involves both historical accounts and mythological interpretations. It is important to note that Menelaus, as a historical or mythological figure, was not killed in Troy. Instead, he was a king of Sparta and a key figure in the Trojan War, which is the central narrative of Homer's epic poem, the "Iliad."
According to the mythological accounts, Menelaus was married to Helen, who was considered the most beautiful woman in the world. The abduction of Helen by Paris, a prince of Troy, was the catalyst for the Trojan War. Menelaus, along with his brother Agamemnon, led the Greek forces against the Trojans to reclaim Helen and restore honor to the house of Atreus.
In the various narratives of the Trojan War, Menelaus is depicted as a brave and skilled warrior. As you mentioned, according to Hyginus, a Latin author who wrote a collection of myths, Menelaus killed eight men in the war and was one of the Greeks hidden inside the Trojan Horse. This was a pivotal moment in the war, as the horse was a deceptive gift from the Greeks, which, when brought inside the city walls of Troy, led to the city's downfall.
During the sack of Troy, Menelaus sought to avenge the death of his brother Agamemnon by killing Deiphobus, who had married Helen after the death of Paris. This act of vengeance is well-documented in the mythological accounts and is often cited as a demonstration of Menelaus's loyalty and his commitment to avenging his family's honor.
It is also worth mentioning that Menelaus's survival and return to Sparta after the Trojan War is a significant part of the story. In Homer's "Odyssey," which tells the story of Odysseus's journey home after the war, Menelaus is portrayed as having a long and arduous journey back to his kingdom. He is said to have encountered various adventures and met with different gods and goddesses, which further adds to the mythological richness of his character.
In conclusion, the question of who killed Menelaus in Troy is based on a misunderstanding. Menelaus was not killed in the war; instead, he played a crucial role as a leader and warrior. His actions, particularly in avenging his brother and reclaiming his wife, are central to the mythological narratives of the Trojan War. The stories of Menelaus's heroism, his trials, and his eventual return home continue to be a source of fascination and study for those interested in the ancient world and its legends.

read more >>

According to Hyginus, Menelaus killed eight men in the war, and was one of the Greeks hidden inside the Trojan Horse. During the sack of Troy, Menelaus killed Deiphobus, who had married Helen after the death of Paris.read more >>