As a historian with a focus on the Tudor period, I find the relationship between Mary, Queen of Scots, and Elizabeth I to be a fascinating subject. It is a story of family, power, and the complex interplay of religion and politics during a tumultuous era in European history.
Mary Stuart, also known as Mary, Queen of Scots, was born in 1542 and was the great-niece of Henry VIII. This familial connection is key to understanding the claim to the English throne that many believed she held.
Elizabeth I, on the other hand, was Henry VIII's daughter and ascended to the English throne in 1558 following the death of her half-sister, Mary I (also known as Mary Tudor).
The relationship between the two queens was complicated by several factors. Firstly, there was the issue of legitimacy. Elizabeth was the daughter of Henry VIII and Anne Boleyn, whose marriage was later annulled, leading to questions about Elizabeth's legitimacy. In the eyes of many Catholics, Elizabeth was considered illegitimate, and Mary Stuart, as the senior descendant of Henry VIII's elder sister, Margaret Tudor, was seen by some as the rightful queen of England.
Secondly, there was the religious divide. Elizabeth was a Protestant, while Mary was a Catholic. This religious difference played a significant role in the political dynamics of the time. The Catholic Church did not recognize the annulment of Henry VIII's marriage to Anne Boleyn, which further fueled the belief that Mary was the legitimate heir to the English throne.
The death of Mary's mother, Mary of Guise, on 11 June 1560, brought the question of future relations between France and Scotland (referred to as Franco-Scots relations) to the forefront. Mary, who was already the Queen of Scotland in her own right, had been married to the Dauphin of France, Francis, making her the Queen of France as well upon his accession to the throne. However, Francis's death in 1560 left Mary a widow and prompted her return to Scotland, where she would face a different set of challenges in her quest to maintain power and navigate the religious tensions of the time.
The rivalry between the two queens was further exacerbated by Mary's claim to the English throne, which Elizabeth I could not ignore. This led to a complex political and diplomatic game, with Mary's actions and alliances being closely watched by Elizabeth and her advisors. The situation was further complicated by plots and intrigues, including the Ridolfi plot of 1571, which was a plan to overthrow Elizabeth and place Mary on the English throne.
Ultimately, Mary's actions and the perceived threat she posed to Elizabeth's reign led to her downfall. She was imprisoned in England by Elizabeth's orders and later executed in 1587 after being found guilty of treason for her involvement in the Babington Plot, which was another attempt to assassinate Elizabeth and put Mary on the English throne.
In conclusion, Mary, Queen of Scots, and Elizabeth I were indeed related, being cousins through their shared Tudor lineage. However, their relationship was marked by rivalry, religious differences, and political tensions that would ultimately lead to Mary's execution and a lasting impact on the history of both England and Scotland.
read more >>

Yet, in the eyes of many Catholics, Elizabeth was illegitimate, and Mary Stuart, as the senior descendant of Henry VIII's elder sister, was the rightful queen of England. ... On 11 June 1560, their sister (Mary's mother) died, and so the question of future Franco-Scots relations was a pressing one.read more >>