best answer > Can you use sand to melt ice 2024?- QuesHub | Better Than Quora
The most authoritative answer in 2024
  • Zoe Reed——Studied at the University of Barcelona, Lives in Barcelona, Spain.

    Hello, I'm a thermal engineer with expertise in heat transfer and phase change processes. I've been working in this field for over a decade and have a deep understanding of the principles governing heat exchange and material behavior.

    Let's dive into the question of using sand to melt ice. The simple answer is no, sand alone cannot melt ice. Here's why:

    * Heat Transfer: Melting ice requires energy, specifically heat energy, to break the bonds holding the water molecules in a solid state. Sand, on its own, doesn't possess a significant amount of heat energy to transfer to the ice.
    * Thermal Conductivity: Sand is a relatively poor thermal conductor, meaning it doesn't transfer heat efficiently. Even if sand were heated, it would struggle to transfer that heat to the ice effectively.
    * Specific Heat Capacity: Sand has a lower specific heat capacity than water. This means it takes less energy to raise the temperature of sand compared to water. So, even if you could heat the sand enough, the ice would likely absorb a significant portion of that heat without melting completely.

    **However, sand can play a role in melting ice indirectly:**

    * Solar Energy Absorption: Sand can absorb solar radiation effectively. If you spread sand over ice and expose it to sunlight, the sand would absorb solar energy and become warmer. This warmth could then be transferred to the ice, albeit slowly due to sand's poor conductivity.
    * Insulation: Sand can also act as a thermal insulator, slowing down the rate of heat loss from the ice. If you bury ice in sand, it can protect the ice from the colder air above, potentially prolonging its lifespan.

    **In conclusion, sand itself won't melt ice directly. It requires a source of heat energy, like sunlight, to warm the sand, and even then, the process will be slow and inefficient due to sand's poor thermal conductivity. However, sand can play a supporting role by absorbing sunlight or acting as an insulator.**

    Let me know if you have any further questions or want to explore this concept in more detail. I'm always happy to discuss these fascinating aspects of thermal physics.
    read more >>
    +149932024-08-01 12:53:25
  • Levi Martinez——Works at Reddit, Lives in San Francisco, CA

    While workers use salt to melt ice, they rely on sand for improved traction. Sand crystals increase friction and help prevent vehicle tires from slipping on slick roads, making travel easier for drivers. Sand can also help prevent new ice from forming on roads.read more >>
    +119962023-04-24 04:07:42

About “thermal engineer、no, sand alone cannot melt ice、Heat Transfer:”,people ask:

READ MORE:

QuesHub is a place where questions meet answers, it is more authentic than Quora, but you still need to discern the answers provided by the respondents.

分享到

取消