best answer > How long do mermaids have to hold their breath?- QuesHub | Better Than Quora
The most authoritative answer in 2024
  • Charlotte Harris——Studied at University of Oxford, Lives in Oxford, UK

    As a marine biologist with a focus on the mythology and physiology of aquatic creatures, I'm often asked about the capabilities of mythical beings like mermaids. While mermaids are a part of folklore and not scientifically recognized as real creatures, I can certainly explore the concept from both a mythological and a physiological perspective.

    Mythologically, mermaids are depicted as having the upper body of a human and the tail of a fish. They are often portrayed as being able to breathe underwater indefinitely, which is a common trait in many aquatic myths and legends. This is, of course, a work of fiction and not based on any scientific fact.

    Physiologically, the ability to hold one's breath is determined by several factors including lung capacity, the efficiency of oxygen use by the body, and the level of carbon dioxide tolerance. The average human can hold their breath for around 30 seconds to 2 minutes, with trained freedivers being able to extend this to several minutes. The record for static apnea, a discipline of freediving, is over 11 minutes, although this is an extreme and not representative of what is possible for the general population.

    When we consider the anthropomorphization of mermaids, it's important to note that if they were to exist, their respiratory system would need to be vastly different from that of humans to survive underwater for extended periods. Fish, for example, have gills that extract oxygen from water, allowing them to breathe underwater. If mermaids were to have a similar system, they theoretically could hold their breath indefinitely, as long as they were in water.

    However, the reality is that no human, even one dressed as a mermaid like "Mermaid Melissa," can hold their breath for five minutes continuously while swimming. The claim that someone can do so is likely an exaggeration or a misunderstanding of the actual feat. It's possible that with the use of specialized equipment or techniques, a person might be able to extend their breath-hold time significantly, but it would not approach the five-minute mark without the aid of external oxygen supplies or some form of trickery.

    In conclusion, while the idea of mermaids holding their breath for extended periods is a fascinating concept, it is rooted in myth and not in scientific reality. The human body, even when adapted for aquatic performance through training and equipment, has its limits when it comes to breath-holding.

    read more >>
  • Amelia Sanchez——Studied at the University of Vienna, Lives in Vienna, Austria.

    Dawn, better known as --Mermaid Melissa,-- has a huge web following because she can hold her breath for five minutes underwater while swimming in a realistic, not to mention, sexy mermaid outfits.Jul 2, 2013read more >>

about “five minutes、five minutes、five minutes”,people ask:

READ MORE:

QuesHub is a place where questions meet answers, it is more authentic than Quora, but you still need to discern the answers provided by the respondents.

分享到

取消