Let me introduce myself. I am a linguist specializing in the Indo-Aryan language family, with a particular focus on the languages spoken in the Indian subcontinent. My research delves into the historical development, dialectal variations, and sociolinguistic aspects of these languages.

Now, regarding your question: "Is Marwari a language?"

This seemingly straightforward question requires a more nuanced response than a simple "yes" or "no." To truly understand the linguistic status of Marwari, we need to delve into its history, examine its relationship with other languages, and consider the socio-political factors that influence its classification.

Historical and Linguistic Context:

Marwari falls under the umbrella of the Indo-Aryan language family, which in turn belongs to the vast Indo-European language family. It is primarily spoken in the Marwar region of Rajasthan, India, as well as in parts of Gujarat, Haryana, and Sindh in Pakistan.

Historically, Marwari evolved from *Apabhramsha*, a stage in the development of Indo-Aryan languages that marked a transition from Middle Indo-Aryan languages like Prakrit to Modern Indo-Aryan languages. This evolution, however, was not a linear process. As people migrated and interacted, dialects diverged and converged, creating a complex linguistic landscape.

The Language vs. Dialect Debate:

The primary reason for the ambiguity surrounding Marwari's status lies in the blurred lines between what constitutes a "language" and a "dialect." Linguistically, distinguishing the two is not always clear-cut. There's a saying, often attributed to linguist Max Weinreich, that highlights this ambiguity: "A language is a dialect with an army and a navy."

This humorous adage underscores the socio-political factors that often play a significant role in determining the official status of a language. Languages that enjoy political patronage, economic power, and standardized forms of writing are more likely to be recognized as distinct languages, while those spoken by smaller communities might be relegated to the status of "dialects."

Marwari's Case:

Marwari displays characteristics that could be argued to support both classifications:

Arguments for "Language":

* Distinct Linguistic Features: Marwari possesses its own unique set of phonetic, lexical (vocabulary), and grammatical features that distinguish it from other languages, including Hindi, which it is often grouped with.
* Literary Tradition: Marwari boasts a rich literary history, with poetry, folk songs, and religious texts written in the language.
* Mutual Intelligibility: While speakers of some Marwari dialects may find it relatively easy to understand and be understood by speakers of certain Hindi dialects, this is not universally true. There are numerous Marwari dialects, and the degree of mutual intelligibility with Hindi can vary significantly.

Arguments for "Dialect":

* Lack of Standardization: Unlike Hindi, which benefits from official language status and standardized grammar and orthography, Marwari lacks a universally accepted standard form.
* Political Factors: The historical dominance of Hindi, particularly after India's independence, has led to Marwari often being considered a dialect of Hindi, even though linguistically, they are distinct.

Conclusion:

So, is Marwari a language or a dialect? The answer is not simple. From a purely linguistic standpoint, Marwari possesses sufficient distinct features to be considered a separate language. However, socio-political factors have contributed to its classification as a dialect in many contexts.

Ultimately, the debate surrounding Marwari's status reflects the broader complexities of language classification, highlighting the interplay of linguistic, historical, and socio-political influences. The key takeaway is that language is not just a tool for communication; it's also deeply intertwined with identity, culture, and power dynamics.

=====

让我自我介绍一下。我是一名语言学家，专门研究印欧语系，特别是印度次大陆的语言。我的研究深入探讨了这些语言的历史发展、方言变异和社会语言学方面。

现在，关于你的问题：“马尔瓦里语是一种语言吗？”

这个看似简单的问题需要比简单的“是”或“否”更细致的回答。要真正理解马尔瓦里语的语言地位，我们需要深入研究它的历史，考察它与其他语言的关系，并考虑影响其分类的社会政治因素。

历史和语言背景：

马尔瓦里语属于印欧语系中的印度-雅利安语族。它主要在印度拉贾斯坦邦的马尔瓦尔地区使用，也在古吉拉特邦、哈里亚纳邦和巴基斯坦的信德省部分地区使用。

从历史上看，马尔瓦里语是从*Apabhramsha*演变而来的，*Apabhramsha*是印度-雅利安语发展的一个阶段，标志着从中印度-雅利安语（如 Prakrit...read more >>

Marwari (M��rw��?��; also rendered Marwadi, Marvadi) is a Rajasthani language spoken in the Indian state of Rajasthan. Marwari is also found in the neighboring state of Gujarat and Haryana, Eastern Pakistan and some migrant communities in himalayan country Nepal. ... The state of Rajasthan recognizes Rajasthani as a language.read more >>